01 – Digests & Extracts
Eivind and Doug talks about Digests and Extracts.
Topics in this episode:
- Why did they make them?
- What makes a good edit?
- Do they have their place today?
- Extracts vs Digests
In this episode
-
Eivind Mork
Host
-
Douglas Warren
Host
Chapters
Transcript
Welcome to the first episode of the Humming Projector podcast, a podcast about film, projectors and film collecting. My name is Eivind Mork and some of you might recognize my name from the Super 8 database project. Although I do indeed run that project too, this podcast is not directly connected to it. Where Super 8 database covers just Super 8, this podcast will cover all gauges. That said, as I and my friends are mostly into 8mm and 16mm, these gauges will be somewhat more in focus than the others. I need to add that I am not an authority at all in this world of film and collecting, just an enthusiast that wants to share my enjoyment of this hobby. But hopefully it will be of interest for both experienced and new collectors. And with that introduction, we are ready to move on to our first episode's topic.
Today I am here with my long-time friend Douglas Warren. How are you doing today, Doug? Oh, doing just fine. How about you? I'm doing fine. At least now we can share with the audience that we have had some technical issues for this first recording. So we have had several attempts for this introduction. So if we seemed a little bit rusty on the introduction, that might be why. In today's episode, we'll talk about Digests and Extracts. And I guess all of you listeners would know the difference. But in case someone is totally new to the scene, we can try to explain the difference between a Digest and Extract. A Digest is where you edit a whole movie into a short sequence, small parts of the movie into a short sequence. And an Extract is one part taken out of the movie. And let's start with the question: Why are there so many Digests? When I talk to my colleagues and friends, they don't understand the point of watching a Digest at all. So why did it even exist in the first place? I think the reason Digest came around was when you think about the time period that these products were produced. In the 70s, you know, there weren't VCRs. I mean, either you went to the movies or you waited a year or two for a movie to come to television. So I think Digest became popular because at least it gave you a nice souvenir of the movie. And, you know, this was a big thing before the videotape scene exploded in the 1980s. I remember, you know, you would walk in, speaking regarding to the United States, you'd walk into department stores and in the photography department you'd see racks of movies. That was a pretty exciting thing, really. Just to even have, you know, something that you knew was just going to be a few scenes, but still you owned a part of the movie. And that was a very exciting thing. But unfortunately, as we know, when videos, the VHS market especially, took off, we saw the quick decline of Super 8 on the whole, as far as the consumer product was concerned. Yes, and the cost, of course, was a big, big deal. When we look at the – I took a look at the Walton catalogue from 1979 and a 400 digest would cost 27 pounds at that time. That's the equal of 33 US dollars. And today's prices, that's 6.47 times as high as average prices since 1979, according to the Office for National Statistics composite price index in the UK. Okay, so that would mean in today's price that would be 175 pounds or 214 US dollars. That's quite a hefty price for 400 feet of film. Yeah, I mean, for what essentially amounts to 16 to 18 minutes of film. I remember 1980-81, the last catalogue, so here in the US that Ken Films put out, their 400 foot Color Sound Digest were going for about 70 US dollars. And you take in inflation now, that's, like you said, it would be considerably more even in today's dollars. I mean, which means, you know, 70 dollars was still a lot of money back then for, again, a small amount of film. Yeah, so we can just imagine how a full movie would have cost. Oh yeah, I remember, you know, I'm old enough to remember the catalogs back then, and this was like, I'll use a timeframe in 1981 again. And I remember seeing, I think it was War of the Worlds had been released as a full Super 8 feature. Now this was in 1981 dollars, and it was nearly 400 dollars, US dollars at the time. That would translate into over a thousand dollars in today's money. That's a lot of money for a single movie. Yeah, and it kind of still applies today, because the full movies are expensive to get today as well. So, I guess the same mechanics still exist today. When we can't afford the full movie, we will still have to kind of have fun with a shorter version. Oh, absolutely. As they say, you know, the film hobby's never been a cheap one. It's an expensive hobby. It always has been. It's never been cheap. And I think for the average consumer back in the day, that's probably one of the reasons like the little 200-foot editions were popular, because at least compared to like 400 and larger, they were considerably more affordable. Even then, they weren't the cheapest by, you know, the money standards of the time, but still. I think that's why they produced so many of them. I mean, some of the first sound films, I believe that Ken Films that was extremely popular, was the Pliny the Apes series, which they never released in anything other than the 200 format. I think we've all had one or a few of those at one time. If you collect Super 8, everybody likes sales films. But today the things are a little bit different, because most of us can see the full movie on Netflix or anywhere else on Blu-ray perhaps. True. Why do we still like to watch Digests instead of the full movie on Netflix? I guess it's a cheat question, because it applies for all things we do in this hobby. But what are your thoughts on that question? My feelings about it, the reason why I still collect Digests, and I want to put something forth: I am mainly a Digest collector. I only have one or two Super 8 features in my entire collection. For me, it's more of a nostalgia thing, because I got into this in my teens back in the 70s, and even more so in the 80s when I was in my 20s. And for me, that's where a lot of it lies. It's nostalgia. I have good memories of that period. You know, I can remember when you'd get films, and it was so exciting to unwrap that film, you know, and pop it on the projector. I couldn't wait to watch a new or used film. I mean, it was just exciting. And I still feel that way. You know, and that's probably another reason that explains our general demographic and the hobby. Most people you see in the hobby tend to be older. People who remember the glory days of it. Yeah, absolutely. Nostalgia plays into it. I'm a bit younger than you, but it still applies to me. I remember Super 8 from the 80s. But one more thing for me as well, because often the thing for me is to play with the films and play with the projector and just hear it humming and not necessarily watch the full movie. So for me it has its place as well because I like the thing to change real, look at different things and then suddenly Digests looks a little bit better. And not necessarily I want to commit to one and a half hour or even more watching a full movie. I think that definitely is a factor that plays in. One of my film collecting friends, he had quite a few features. He sold them all and he decided to stick with Digests because he's a very busy guy. And he said he loved the fact that he can sit down and in an hour he can run three Digests and still enjoy film. The time factor plays into it. I'm sorry, go ahead. No, go ahead. I was just going to say that even the features I've had, I keep them - a lot of the collectors I know like mounting them on larger reels. I've always kept them on the 400- or 600-foot reels because I may just want to watch a portion of it that day and I'll come back to it a day or two later and watch another part. You know? Yeah. Time factor. And when the point is, perhaps a big part of the point is to go back in the memory lane, it's probably good as well to watch different titles, not only just one title for the time you have to watch this. Absolutely. At least it's like that for me. Absolutely. Same. There's also one more point for me, why Digests could be interesting: that some movies might be long and boring and actually get a little bit better when you cut it down so you can see some parts of it. At least I can think about a few titles perhaps that way. Oh, I absolutely agree with that. Some films work way better as a Digest than they ever did as a feature-length film. Absolutely. So, let's look at a different part of this, and that is the art of editing. Because it's not easy to compress a full movie into this short, I mean, 80 minutes for a 400 and perhaps 7 minutes for a 200. So, what makes an edit good? That's a difficult question, but what kind of thoughts do you have on that question? I think, for me, it depends upon - it's really on a film-by-film basis, a more action-packed film. You know, you're, of course, going to want those various scenes that you remember from the movie, you know, that made the movie memorable in the first place. As long as they're edited logically, you know, and some of the story remains, you know, that'll be - you know, like Star Wars, you know, we know all the famous scenes. The story has a lot more plot. That's generally going to be a harder edit. And, you know, I think it really is on a film-by-film basis. I mean, I've seen some Digests that are just beautifully edited. A fairly obscure film - I'm going to use this as an example - and I've seen the original - I've seen the full-length film twice, and so I know what I'm watching. It's a film called Emperor of the North, and that was one of the best - this is from Ken Films - to me, one of the best edited - 400 foot digest they ever released i mean it was just beautifully done and i remember watching it thinking why can't they all be edited this well you know um but i think that's really what it boils down to it's a film by film basis if it's an action movie put in the best scenes but again if it's um a film with a more intricate plot line well you're gonna have you're gonna have a little more work to do and unfortunately as we both know some digests fail in that regards yeah they feel terribly one thing that i have been thinking about this um what is the audience you are editing for because when i was watching rare eagles there that's not a digest as such a more an abridged version of three by four hundred where i watched that with my wife and i know that story really well and watched the the full movie many times and i really like that um abridged version really well but i do know the full story uh so uh when you know the full story perhaps you select a little bit different scenes than what you would do if you present it to the viewer that watched it for the first time because my wife really absolutely did not follow the story and i can understand why because it's a complex story so i for me it's probably um depending on uh what the audience would be and i guess for most people they would absolutely know the story from before they would never have bought an expensive film like that and not knowing the film from before so it's more looking back at the film so um i guess that was really important part of the the editing process thinking about what what are the most memorable parts of the movie more than how to make it flow really well but i don't know um in families probably one would know it well and perhaps the wife or or the husband of the projectionist didn't know that that well so it makes it difficult though but um um um taking out of different kind of films like the Genevieve from 1953 that's a derived 600 release and i have that one and that's just a cross-country race with a vintage car and and and two people make a bet and try to sabotage each other and that's really really simple to edit because you you can cut out any part you like because they do different kind of sabotages and and the car breakdowns and you really don't mess up the full story and no matter how you edit it um so so that would require something completely different to to edit and another example is the Anderson tapes from 1971 a Columbia release with Sean Connery about a person getting out of jail and and taking part in a robbery and the whole whole part is a robbery i've never seen the full movie but it works really well because you well you get the robbery right yeah you can build up so you can cut out any scene you you like so um absolutely the the complexity of the story is really crucial on how well the edit will be i fully agree on that i also feel that uh the nature of film in general you know digest most people again and you brought up a good point anybody putting that amount of money out knows the film they know what they're getting you know they've seen more i'd say more likely not they've seen the film so they're not buying uh of course i know some collectors have said oh i picked this up and this is the first time i ever saw anything of this particular film was on a digest and that's great but i think you know eventually you know you're gonna want to see the whole film but i do feel though i mean like when i used to make film lists of films i wanted it was all films that i had seen you know i didn't want to like you know drop a hundred dollars on us dollars on something i had never seen because what if it turns out to be a turkey you know so i think that definitely uh plays into it and if you look at the titles released too that says something you know they were going for i guess the popular films at whatever given time not always the case but more often than that was. Yeah and and uh i just remembered um at the Blackpool Film Collectors Convention in in in November uh Jed Jones from the former uh Duran director um had a Q&A session with Adrian Winchester and he mentioned something where his first uh edit of a of a of a movie to make a digest of it was a plane plane movie and you can't really go that wrong on a plane movie uh because yeah planes flying you can cut anything you like and and and keep cool scenes so um but a complex story makes it really difficult and and um Colombia made one uh one way of uh of handling this problem of complex stories we all know the commentaries of Colombia what do you think about that? The notorious Colombia narrator oh yes uh uh it's really sad because Colombia uh had good edits on the whole but if they had just dropped the narration they would have been i think they would actually be a lot more collectible but the narration they went overboard with it so bad i wound up personally selling off several Colombia titles because i just couldn't get past the over-the-top narration and a lot of times it was so unintentionally funny i'd be laughing at what the narrator was saying because it was so unnecessary and i think they kind of they didn't help their reputation any with that personally no they tried to to to fix a complex story with this but it really takes you out of the movie and and uh and to the side of the movie as a spectator on a further distance for me at least not i don't feel like i'm in the movie when i watch the Colombia commentaries but there's one one thing for me um let's first discuss the difference of a 200 digest and 400 digest um and then i'll make a different point of this um how do you think 200 uh digest works compared to to a 400? I think again with that it depends upon the uh manufacturer because if you take like Castle which eventually became Universal 8 they originally were they they originally were nothing but 200 foot extracts back then of course they had the best editors on the market i mean those are that's still some of the best uh eight millimeter uh digest editing to this day um my personal opinion on 200 foot digest i always looked at them more as an extended trailer than i did anything because you only have seven to eight minutes of film and that's my feelings on them some have been done really well but there were a lot that were not done so well that's my own opinion the 400 foot ones of course you do get more film and uh you got more time and room to do an edit you know you can make it a much better edit yeah and all the problems we have with the digest on 400 multiplies when it gets down to 200 of course and but you you took my point exactly this is what was i was what i was going to say uh the 200s have a lot of similarities to the trailers indeed uh that's what i was thinking about before this episode as well and that got me a little bit puzzled because trailers often have commentaries to explain some of the plot and i do not mind on trailers but on Digests for some reason i i really don't like the commentaries but so so that's a little bit strange thing for me uh but i get it's the concept of trailers not being uh you don't feel like you are in the movie you are uh we we know the concept of being explained what the movie is about i guess absolutely absolutely uh one of my favorite uh 200 foot digest that also translated into a wonderful 400 foot digest was the old jimmy stewart film flight of the phoenix um i have the 200 foot one i no longer have the 400 foot and they're both beautifully done and thankfully no narration on either one and whoever edited that did a wonderful job it flows so well on the key scenes from the movie are in there they just they should have held on to that editor because he did a fantastic job one of my favorite 200 foot digest by far yeah which proves that you can you can do it i mean uh everybody knows jaws remember the 200 foot jaws digest a fantastic digest from universal 8 probably uh that would to me qualify as the best in that length as far as editing yeah i think i agree um you have probably seen a lot more than me but i agree that draws is wonderful on 200 and then we can look at the extracts a bit perhaps because and we said we'll talk about digests and extracts and we have only talked about digest so far do you prefer digest or or extracts um i'd have to say i lean more towards digest but i'm also a fan of extracts but with extracts not many people did them really disney was the main company that did extracts and they did them very very well um i've got about three or four of those in my collection and they're just disney did a fantastic job on them i mean they really did i know i've seen some collectors bash extracts i disagree with that because um if there's a particular scene that you really like and disney was great about picking that one scene that everybody would talk about and pulling that as the extract for their films and they always did a good job with it because i'm i'm trying to think other than disney who really did extracts so maybe there's some of the foreign producers that did disney's only one that really comes to mind for me yeah um disney are more than animations but uh um when you get to animations i i i was thinking for me extracts work better for animations than and live movies absolutely i wondered why i think so and when i was thinking about it i think it it for me it's a lot down to for animations i'm take short cartoons Donald Duck or something you are used to jumping into the some random action and you you buy that concept of jumping right into some some random action uh where i have not much explaining in beforehand so for me it's a little bit about the same when you take an extract from an animation a full movie and one and a half hour animation and you take one part of it it feels more like a cartoon where you are okay with not knowing everything you you you you buy the concept of seeing a character uh in some action um and i can't explain it better than that i think because um for for for a live action movie you you wouldn't like buy in the same way by the premise of jumping right into some some live action in the same sense right right right well again i think i personally think it depends upon the um the film you know i have a lot of 200 200 foot digest i have actually that's the bulk of my collection believe it or not and again it works with some some not so much um but uh to me the most successful were probably the castle films horror and science fiction titles they did a fantastic job with only eight minutes i mean you totally get the gist of the film when that short eight minutes you know and those worked really well you know they demand the high prices now unfortunately that's another topic we can eventually talk about is the cost of film these days and how so the market's getting kind of crazy out there yeah yeah and that's another point because many of the digest were sold in so huge numbers so in today's prices uh you get the uh digest and and cut down so much more easily than the the full version of course and like take the the match of the century from disney for instance you you find that everywhere so the price will never be insane um so it's a good starting point i guess for any collector of course to to get there yeah what i don't understand is like why is star wars star wars original digest so expensive when that was one of the most produced digest on the market they produce tons of those why are they so expensive yeah you know i don't get that but supply and demand i guess i don't know there was one interesting point that i wasn't aware of that a friend of mine tony lewis was mentioning to me and that there was um when some of the distributors made digests um at 400 and the 200 often they didn't uh pick all the same scenes in those two versions the 200 is not just a shorter version of the 400 then it might have different scenes as well so some people are collecting the 400 and the 200 of some release and and uh cut it together and make a longer digest than the 400 was and in some cases you perhaps even have extracts as well and then you can uh make an even longer version um so um back to editing the film um what works on the 400 perhaps didn't work on the 200 so the scenes were not the same yeah this i i agree with that i agree with that um uh mentioning uh people taking a 200 foot you know digest and editing editing editing it with a 400 foot digest to get a you know a much longer film i know speaking of star wars again uh that was the famous one that people did that with because what you got in the 200 foot one i think was essentially different than what eventually got released in the 400 foot edition and a lot of people did that to have a longer film made a lot more exciting too and it's fun i like editing i like sitting down working physically with my films and i like doing that myself yeah i'm a bit torn because in one one part of me would like to do it and the other part would like hate to cut any existing existing digest i understand yeah i i understand that you don't want to spoil the original product no no that's probably all the points i had on this subject um do you have anything you want to add doug that's pretty much it um i think we covered the uh digest topic pretty well and extracts and so forth um i think we i think we covered it pretty much unless you want to do a part two eventually maybe cover even more undiscovered ground perhaps we could do that if we get some feedback on the matter and and and talking about feedback if you listen to this and have some thoughts you want to share or some points we missed uh please share your thoughts by sending an email to feedback at hummingprojector.com and tell us what you what you think uh we would love to have a hear you uh your feedback and even if you say some positive things about the show or you have some critics to the show or you would tell us about something we missed we would love to hear from you so please send your feedback to feedback at hummingprojector.com and with that we have reached the end of this episode um i'm evan mojk and with me is douglas warring and thanks for listening it was fun thanks guys